|
Dr.
Tom's Independent Software Reviews
presents:
|
DeLorme
Topo USAT 2.0
|
|
|
Introduction:
Since
1976, the only widespread available topographic maps are published by
the Maine based company DeLorme (DeLorme's Atlas and Gazetteer series).
In spite of their commitment to topographic maps, DeLorme exclusively
produced street maps and atlases when they moved to computer mapping in
the mid 1980s. Their "Street Atlas USA" has become America's
best selling mapping software. Fortunately, in the early 1990s, DeLorme
decided to create a software version of their popular "Atlas and
Gazetteer" series, which was called "Topo USA". Up to now,
Topo USA is the only low-cost topographic mapping software available which
covers the entire USA. As Topo's maps allow you to zoom-in up to a scale
of 1:24.000, 6 CDs or 1 DVD are necessary to contain all cartographic
materials.
The
user interface of Topo USA is intuitive and easy to learn. For an introduction
of its features, please click on either of the screenshots below!!
|
|
Fig.
1: Detail Level 9-0
Please click on the image for a closer look!
|
Fig.
2: Detail Level 12-4
Please click on the image for a closer look!
|
top
Features:
Map
View and "Find" Feature:
Let's
begin with Topo USA's search-and-find options. If you are looking for
a city/town or a specific landmark, just enter the name into the "Search
for" field. Then select the state. If you are using the 6 CDs version,
you do well to start Topo USA with the right CD in your CD-drive, otherwise
you face one of the shortcomings of the application. You have to shut
down Topo, insert the right CD and start up again. If you started with
the right CD, you may either use global or local search. The Global Index
option conducts a broad search and is designed for searches in the entire
US or an individual state. The Local Index option offers a more detailed
search and should be used when searching for any point of interest within
a specific city, e.g. a certain street, or geographic features within
a particular radius. In my test it was sufficient to use the global index.
I was looking for a local state park in central PA (Pine Grove Furnace),
thus starting Topo using the CD: Northeast. Typing in "pine grove"
and selecting Pennsylvania yielded an alphabetically sorted list containing
several exact and approximate matches. After clicking on "Pine Grove
Furnace", the map view window centered on the selected feature and
automatically inserted a name tag. As the chosen feature only appears
in higher magnification, Topo displayed this first map in already detailed
scale (12-4). Simultaneously, with the main map view, the overview map
also centered on the chosen landmark and displayed the further surroundings
of the Pine Grove Furnace state park. On the right side, the corresponding
geographical data are displayed. The map provides intuitive color patterns,
which can be switched to night settings for easier perception when using
Topo USA in the dark. Both displays resemble the natural conditions of
the landscape and vegetation cover. Besides searching for landmarks in
the global and local scale, you can find features by typing-in known latitude
and longitude. Every detail map and most of the advanced features (see
below) can be printed out into nice paper maps even on an average quality
color ink jet printer.
top
Fig.
3: Detail Level 15-0
Please
click on the image for a closer look!
top
Detail
Levels:
Each map can be viewed in fourteen magnitudes (2-0 to 15-0) each consisting
of eight octaves (0 to 7), resulting in a total of 112 zoom levels. Detail
level 2-0 displays the entire United States. As you zoom in to higher
detail levels, you see less geographic area and more geographic detail.
However, most of the detail levels do not reveal more geographic details
but simply enlarge the area. I could only find an increase in information
when switching to the next full magnitude level (e.g. 2-7 to 3-0). The
octaves simply show the selected area in a closer look. Even switching
to the next full magnitude does not always result in more detail (e.g.
from 8-7 to 9-0). Especially at the top end of Topo's detail levels, zooming-in
only results in more location names and contour lines leaving the rest
of the map unchanged. This is what is called "empty enlargements"!
As DeLorme got its know-how in computer mapping from street atlases, zoom-into
urban areas (cities and townships, refer to Figs. 1-3) offers more details
than zooming into off-road areas (refer to Fig. 4). The MapDoc function
of Topo USA 2.0 allows you to save any map view so that you can easily
access it again later. Saved map views have there own file extension *.TP2
and are saved into the C:\DeLorme Docs\MapDocs directory by default. A
MapDoc consists of the latitude/longitude of the map center, the current
detail level and the current photo zoom.
Fig.
4: Zoom Series Urban Area
Please
click on the image for a closer look!
top
3-D
Option:
Another nice feature of Topo USA which is usually only included into much
more expensive packages, is the the possibility to render any selected
map view into a 3 dimensional topographic perspective (3-D option). Compared
to the earlier 1.0 version, DeLorme improved this feature in Topo USA
2.0 by including a new, more realistic 3-D engine and more realistic shading
and land coloring. The perspective views are displayed in a separate window
and change dynamically if you re-center the map to another landmark. As
I conducted my review on a Pentium 133 MHz dinosaur with 64 MB RAM, I
could not enjoy this being the most resource dependent feature of Topo.
I already had to be patient when re-centering maps or changing the detail
level in the 2-D mode but using the 3-D functions dynamically gave my
good old buddy the rest. I was, however, able to conveniently use the
3-D option for single map views. The 3-D control options allow the user
to modify pitch, rotation and vertical exaggeration. If you play a little
around with them, you might end up with a quite realistic appearance of
the mapped landscapes. One shortcoming is however, that you can not modify
the angle of illumination, which would allow much more realistic views.
Fig.
5: 3-D view of the same area as in Fig. 1
Please
click on the image for a closer look!
top
Navigation:
Topo USA can also be used to create individual routes on streets, trails
or through the "outback". In the "Navigate" control
center you may enter either "Shape Points" or "Waypoints".
The Shape Points option creates a route using nodes allowing you to record
complete routes without including a lot of individual waypoints. The Waypoints
option uses waypoints and places a Waypoint Tag each time you click on
the map. They are represented by a label on the map, are included in the
Route Directions and can contain Lat/Lon and Journal entries. Switching
from the Waypoints option to the Shape Points option can be done at any
time when creating your route. If you use a GPS (Global Positioning
System) receiver that supports uploading/downloading, you can even
upload/download routes and waypoints. A summary of the route is displayed
in the Directions window. Route Directions include: e.g. single distances
(legs) , cumulative route distance and bearing for each leg. When using
a GPS receiver, you can track your route in real time and include it in
your route directory. After recording a route in any of the described
ways, you can create an cross-sectional profile of your trip. This feature
allows you to preview hikes or backcountry travels so that you know way
ahead, how exhausting for you or your vehicle the journey may be. Unfortunately,
this very useful feature is only implemented for manually entered routes:
You cannot use the streets, roads and trails in Topo USA although they
are already vector graphics in the application. This is really a shortcoming
of this otherwise great product! In addition, the displayed average grade
of a profiled route is calculated over the entire length. If you are mainly
traveling through flat land but face several steep climbs or inclines,
this measurement does not make a lot of sense. However, if you calculate
only the extreme parts of your travel, the measures become more realistic.
Fig.
6: Navigate with Topo USA: Routes, Directions and Profiles
Please
click on the image for a closer look!
top
MapDraw:
Topo's drawing options allow you to mark maps for example with pins
and named tags (MapNotes: e.g. free text, Lat./Long., distance and bearing)
or draw lines, circles and polygons. You can also get the size of your
drawn objects by clicking the "Show Measurement" option to display
e.g. distance, area and perimeter as you draw. Another nice feature is
that you can save your Draw Objects as a Draw Layer that you can reopen
later-on.
Fig.
7: Some of Topo's Drawing Objects: Colored Pins, MapNotes
and Polygons Including Measurements
top
NetLink:
Topo USA 2.0 combines the usefulness of a nationwide mapping program
with up-to-date online information about scheduled road construction,
weather forecasts and upcoming events relevant for the selected map area.
Once you select to include this information, Topo will check whether you
are connected to the Internet and automatically retrieve the appropriate
updates as you pan your map to different areas. Relevant information for
your current map area is directly displayed in your maps by intuitive
icons for road construction, whether and events. Switching from the map
overview to the query window in the lower right corner of the Topo interface
provides you detailed information on the event when you place the mouse
cursor on the corresponding icon. If available, further details can be
displayed using your default browser (works only with Netscape and MS
Internet Explorer, not with Opera!).
Fig.
8: Up-to-Date Information with NetLink
Please
click on the image for more illustrations!
top
GPS:
Unfortunately,
my old laptop kicked the bucket before I could use it to evaluate Topo
USA 2.0's GPS functions. I could not afford to replace it yet and therefore
was unable to test Topo's GPS features and the integration of DeLorme's
Earthmate GPS receiver which I also intended to test. As I am switching
jobs soon, I might be able to test these functions when conducting my
field studies soon. In the meanwhile, I only present DeLorme's product
description and provide some links to other software reviews covering
this topic at the bottom of this chapter.
From DeLorme's description of Topo's GPS features: "Topo USA 2.0
lets you take advantage of the Global Positioning System (GPS) through
an interface with several DeLorme-recommended GPS receivers. Connected
to DeLorme's GPS receiver, Garmin 30, Trimble Scoutmaster, Magellan, Rockwell
or any other fully compatible NMEA receiver and a CD-ROM-equipped laptop,
you can display a "bread crumb trail" to track your progress as you travel.
Uploaded to Garmin 45 GPS, GPS II, GPS II Plus, GPS III or GPS 12XL hardware,
your Topo USA 2.0 route signals your next turn or Stop. You'll never have
to ask for directions again! If you have a laptop computer you can see
your location on a map in real time as you travel with a GPS receiver
and DeLorme Topo USA 2.0. You'll see the names of mountains, streams and
other geographic features on the map, in addition to seeing your current
position and heading, latitude and longitude coordinates change as you
move." Copyright © 1999 and 2000 DeLorme. All rights reserved.
DeLorme writes about the Earthmate® GPS Receiver: "Never Get Lost
Again! The Earthmate GPS Receiver is a high-performance, easy-to-use link
to the satellite navigation technology of the Global Positioning System
(GPS). Earthmate and a laptop PC will show your location on detailed Street
Atlas USA® [and Topo USA 2.0] maps. An arrow shows your position in real
time on street-level maps, so you always know where you are and where
you need to be. Your Best Choice for Quality GPS Earthmate has been developed
in partnership with Rockwell/Conexant, the company that pioneered GPS
satellite technology. This means you get faster satellite acquisition
times and outstanding performance specifically designed to maximize the
unique capabilities of award-winning Street Atlas USA and other DeLorme
software. Durable with Efficient Power Options Earthmate features a durable
housing with a moisture-resistant seal and is designed to withstand a
wide variety of road conditions. Unlike many other GPS receivers, Earthmate
can be powered by four AAA batteries. This is especially important when
using Earthmate with handheld or laptop computers in a car where available
power is already being used. (Note: to use Earthmate with Palm Computing®
organizers and Windows® CE 2.0 handheld or palm-size PCs, you need the
[free downloadable software] SolusT Pro 1.5 software and additional cables)."
Copyright
© 1999 and 2000 DeLorme. All rights reserved.
The
following reviews tested the GPS feature of DeLorme's Topo USA 2.0 and
or the DeLorme Earthmate® GPS Receiver:
New Media Review: http://nmreview.com/reviews/delorme/index.htm
Alpine Extreme: http://www.alpineextreme.com/reviews/topousa2/
David L. Wilson's GPS Accuracy Web Page: http://users.erols.com/dlwilson/postpro.htm
Joe Mehaffey and Jack Yeazel's GPS Information Website: http://joe.mehaffey.com/ot-20.htm
All-OffRoad Hardware & Software Reviews: http://www.all-offroad.com/DirtBikes/Hardware/Reviews/TopoUSA.html
top
Usage & Evaluation:
Despite
a few shortcomings: changing of regional CDs requires to shut-down Topo
and restarting it using the right CD, missing details in higher resolutions,
inability to profile parts of roads without creating them manually by
way- or shapepoints again, minor mistakes in the calculation of grades
and the inability to change the angle of light in 3-D views, Topo USA
2.0 offers a lot of mapping fun for a large area (the entire USA) at a
very low price: about 100 US $ for the 6 CDs version.
Along with this, everybody who just wants to have a nice software to search
for specific geographical places, get an idea about an area, planning
an off-road trip and print out good-looking and quite detailed maps, can
hardly find a better and cheaper solution. In contrast to this, somebody
in the need of more professional software solutions for topographic maps
with real detail in higher resolutions should consider one of the below
mentioned products. However, he or she has to be prepared to spent much
more money for either of the other products and be restricted on a much
smaller area covered by the cartographic material.
System
Requirements: PC with Intel Pentium 120 MHz (233 MHz recommended);
16 MHz RAM (32 recommended); at least 30 MB HD space; MS Windows 95 or
98; Super VGA card, 16-bit color monitor and mouse; ISO 9660-compatible
CD-ROM drive; for printing: 1.5 MB for 300 dpi printouts, 6 MB for 600
dpi printouts; 3-D accelerator card recommended for 3-D views.
Company
Information: DeLorme; Two DeLorme Drive; P.O. Box 298; Yarmouth, ME
04096, USA; Phone: 207-846-7000; E-mail: support@delorme.com;
URL: http:www.delorme.com
Alternatives:
top
|